In Gambini v. Total Renal care, the court held that an employer cannot terminate or otherwise discipline an employee for misconduct if the misconduct is caused by a disablity.
Stephanie Gambini worked for Davita, a company providing dialysis. She had a history of health problems and diagnosed with bipolar disorder. She was easily distracted, agitated, was angry and irritable. She was called into a meeting, where she was presented with a written performance improvement plan. She threw the plan across the desk and cursed her supervisors, saying they would “regret this.” She slammed the door on the way out, and kicked and threw items about her cubicle after the meeting. Numerous employees noticed DaVita about their concern. She was terminated.
The 9th circuit, including California and the Northwest, said that “conduct resulting from a disability is considered part of the disability, rather than a basis for termination.” This is a departure from precedent, for other circuits do not hold tot his viewpoint. It could signal a change that could play havoc with small business. I cannot imagine such a decision unless there are facts not revealed in the report. As a previous employer, this would be totally unsupportable.
No comments:
Post a Comment